7 signs your website needs a redesign

A website redesign is expensive, disruptive and, done for the wrong reasons, pointless. "It looks old" is not a reason on its own. Losing enquiries because the contact form fails on phones is.
This article lists the seven signs we look for when a client asks whether they need a new site. For each one we explain how to check it yourself and whether it usually calls for a targeted fix or a full rebuild. If three or more apply, a redesign is probably the cheaper option in the medium term.
1. The site is slow, and Core Web Vitals say so
Speed is the first thing visitors notice and the last thing many site owners check. Google publishes three thresholds for a "good" page experience under its Core Web Vitals: a Largest Contentful Paint of 2.5 seconds or less, an Interaction to Next Paint of 200 milliseconds or less, and a Cumulative Layout Shift of 0.1 or less.
How to check: run your home page and a key service page through PageSpeed Insights and read the field data at the top, which reflects real visitors. Then check the Core Web Vitals report in Google Search Console for the whole site.
Fix or rebuild? If the problems are oversized images, missing caching or a slow host, fix them. If the site is built on a heavy page builder with dozens of plugins and every page fails all three metrics, the cost of patching usually exceeds the cost of rebuilding on a lighter foundation.
2. It does not work properly on a phone
For most small businesses, more than half of visits now come from mobile devices, and Google indexes the mobile version of your pages. A site that is merely "responsive" on paper can still be unusable in practice.
How to check: open every important page on your own phone, on mobile data rather than Wi-Fi. Look for text you have to zoom to read, buttons too close together, horizontal scrolling, menus that hide the phone number, and forms that are painful to fill in. Then ask someone outside the company to try to book, buy or contact you from their phone while you watch.
Fix or rebuild? A few layout problems can be patched. If the site was designed desktop-first and mobile was an afterthought, a rebuild with a mobile-first layout is almost always the better call.
3. Traffic is fine but conversions are not
A site can rank well, receive steady traffic and still produce almost no enquiries. That is a design problem, not a marketing problem.
How to check: in GA4, compare sessions with form submissions, calls or purchases over the last six months. Look at the pages where people leave. Watch a few session recordings if you have a tool for it. Common causes: no clear call to action above the fold, a contact form with too many fields, prices or process hidden, no proof of credibility, and unclear service pages that leave visitors unsure what you actually do.
Fix or rebuild? If the structure is sound and the problem sits in a handful of pages, a conversion-focused revision will do. If visitors cannot work out what you sell within a few seconds of landing, the problem is the information architecture and that means a redesign.
4. Accessibility is an afterthought
Accessible websites work for people with visual, motor or cognitive impairments, and they also work better for everyone else: clearer contrast, readable type, keyboard navigation, meaningful headings. In the EU, accessibility requirements now apply to a growing range of digital services, and public sector clients in particular may require it from suppliers.
How to check: run a free automated check such as Lighthouse's accessibility audit or the WAVE browser extension. Then try to navigate your site using only the keyboard. Check that images have alt text, that colour contrast is sufficient, that forms have labels and that videos have captions.
Fix or rebuild? Many accessibility issues are fixable in place. But if the site's theme or builder generates inaccessible markup by default, you will fight it on every page. A rebuild with accessibility designed in from the start is usually cleaner.
5. The technical stack is outdated or fragile
You probably know this one already: the CMS cannot be updated without something breaking, plugins are abandoned, the hosting runs an old PHP version, or the only person who understood the site left years ago.
How to check: ask whoever maintains the site three questions. Is the CMS and every plugin on a current, supported version? When was the last security update applied? What happens if the site goes down on a Saturday? If the answers are vague, so is your security.
Fix or rebuild? An outdated stack is rarely worth salvaging. Migrating to a modern, well-supported setup, whether that is a lean WordPress build, a static site or a headless approach, removes a permanent risk and usually fixes signs one and two along the way.
6. The site no longer matches your business
Businesses change. Services get added or dropped, the audience shifts from local to national, the brand gets refreshed in print and on social media while the website still shows the logo from the previous decade. Visitors notice the gap even when they cannot name it.
How to check: put your website next to your latest proposal, your Instagram grid and your business card. Do they look like the same company? Does the home page describe what you sell today, for whom, and in the words your customers use? Read your About page and your main service pages aloud. If you wince, so do your prospects.
Fix or rebuild? A copy rewrite and a visual refresh can go a long way if the structure still fits. If the structure reflects a business that no longer exists, with pages for services you dropped and nothing for the ones that now pay the bills, start from the strategy and rebuild.
7. Nobody can update it
A website that only a developer can touch stops being updated. News stops, prices go stale, the team page shows people who left. Every change becomes a ticket, a cost and a delay, so changes stop happening.
How to check: time how long it takes someone non-technical in your team to publish a news item, change a price and swap a photo. If the answer is "we have to ask the agency", or the editor is so fragile that people are afraid to touch it, the site is holding the business back.
Fix or rebuild? Sometimes training and a cleaner editor setup are enough. More often, the site was built without thinking about who would maintain it, and a rebuild with a simple, well-structured CMS pays for itself in the first year of saved friction.
Fix or rebuild: how to decide
Count the signs that apply. One or two, concentrated in a specific area, usually mean a targeted project: a performance pass, a conversion review, an accessibility sprint. Three or more, especially if they include an outdated stack, point to a rebuild.
Either way, do not start with design. Start with what the site has to achieve, for whom, and how you will measure it. A redesign that begins with colours and templates tends to reproduce the old problems in a new skin.

